A donor tells a gift officer, "I’m interested. I’m just not sure where I’d want to focus."
Most good fundraisers hear that and start solving. "We have several possibilities. Let me put together some options for you."
It sounds like great service. It’s also the moment the donor stops thinking and the fundraiser takes over. I see this often in the teams I coach, and it’s usually the strongest people doing it. They’re responsive, prepared and quick to fix things. Every nonprofit wants them. And without meaning to, they end up carrying both sides of the relationship.
I know this one from home, too. With teenagers, the fastest way to get something done is to do it myself. Fill out the form. Make the call. Fix the essay. It’s efficient, and it also quietly teaches them the work belongs to me.
Donors aren’t so different. When we do all the work, they stay pleasantly interested, and the relationship looks busy without actually moving.
Overfunctioning looks a lot like competence. Underneath it, there’s often discomfort with uncertainty. Doing something relieves anxiety. Waiting requires confidence.
Here are three questions I use with fundraisers to hand the work back to the donor.
1. "After you do this, what does the donor do, and by when?" Look at the next steps in your CRM. If every one starts with your verb and ends with "we wait," the donor has nothing to do. Keep rewriting until each step ends in a donor commitment on a date.
2. "What question are you bringing this donor that only they can answer?" A visit request built around a real problem your organization is working through gives a donor a reason to engage, not just attend.
3. Are you offering a proposal, or a role? Donors making a big step up rarely get there through a polished proposal. They get there when they’re invited to help shape the thinking. Bring them the unfinished idea and ask them to stress-test it. The gap in your materials is an invitation, not necessarily a problem.
Back to that donor who wasn’t sure where to focus. The stronger response is a simple question:
"What are you weighing?" Then let them answer.
Great fundraisers make giving easier. They also know they can’t manufacture someone else’s conviction. At some point the donor has to pick up their side of the relationship, and a big part of our job is creating space for that to happen.